NooneOfConsequence wrote on Apr 17
th, 2023 at 12:14am:
Ok, IG… now the plot thickens: how about a rusty ball with a tungsten spike in front? Is peak force still more important?
..Yes. The peak force at the front of the spike will be super high because there is a very small area. Even though the rusty ball would lower the peak force compared to a solid mass behind the spike, it is still important.
The thought experiment you are intending would need to be different to negate the importance of peak force...
I'm not sure what you are getting at. I could me mis-interpreting what your intention is, but I don't think that you can equate total energy transfer to damage.
Edit: Ok, so you are thinking elastic vs inelastic collisions.
I guess what I'm supposition-ing (is that a word?) is that even though a hard projectile could have an elastic collision, it most likely won't. It will deform whatever it is hitting via high peak force. Supposing you had something that the projectile hits that is very hard and strong, then an elastic collision could happen, and yes, very little damage to the object (that was hit) would occur. But that would take a lot of material that was very strong. Like a pillar of concrete or a 1/2" metal plate. Most helmets or armor were not that thick. So, for a normal 1mm thick plate of steel, I would stick with my answer of hard being better. And even a rusty ball with a spike would be better than a rustyball alone.
HOwever, put the rock or a rustyball against a person with a 1/2" thick helmet on that wouldn't deform, the rustyball would do better, because maybe you can shock their neck with all of the energy being transferred as opposed to the rock elastically bouncing off and not transferring as much energy.