Welcome, Guest. Please Login
SLINGING.ORG
 
Home Help Search Login


Pages: 1 2 3 4 
Send Topic Print
Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? (Read 15382 times)
Mersa
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline


Druid

Posts: 2673
Australia
Gender: male
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #15 - Apr 17th, 2023 at 3:36am
 
Oh my!!
Impact ballistics discussion incoming!!!

I think the angle at which the projectile strikes is another major factor in the “best/better” discussion.

Water filled object?
Hard outer ?
My mind gets lost very quickly in this stuff. 
There’s so much physics going on I don’t know what outweighs what and where to start to figure it out .

Nooc, Sarosh , Goober !!

Please enlighten us!!
Back to top
 

Razor glandes, Aim for the eyes!!!
 
IP Logged
 
Archaic Arms
Funditor
****
Offline


Testing and inventing
"Archaic" weapons.

Posts: 786
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #16 - Apr 17th, 2023 at 5:22am
 
If the spike had a circular plate attached to the base of it (so as to not puncture the layer of balloons at the rear of the rusty) then I imagine as it hits the target, the redirected force from the rusty ball flattening out will focus behind the spike (especially if the spike meets resistance). The question is, how elastic or inelastic should the 'skin' of the rusty ball be to maximise penetration of the spike? (think balloon rubber vs kevlar fabric)
My guess is, the tougher the target, the less elasticity.
Back to top
 

Regards,
Lewis
WWW  
IP Logged
 
IronGoober
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline


...and now, No. 1, the
larch...

Posts: 2011
California
Gender: male
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #17 - Apr 17th, 2023 at 4:30pm
 
NooneOfConsequence wrote on Apr 17th, 2023 at 12:14am:
Ok, IG… now the plot thickens: how about a rusty ball with a tungsten spike in front?  Is peak force still more important?


..Yes.  The peak force at the front of the spike will be super high because there is a very small area.  Even though the rusty ball would lower the peak force compared to a solid mass behind the spike, it is still important.

The thought experiment you are intending would need to be different to negate the importance of peak force...

I'm not sure what you are getting at. I could me mis-interpreting what your intention is, but I don't think that you can equate total energy transfer to damage.

Edit: Ok, so you are thinking elastic vs inelastic collisions.
I guess what I'm supposition-ing (is that  a word?) is that even though a hard projectile could have an elastic collision, it most likely won't. It will deform whatever it is hitting via high peak force. Supposing you had something that the projectile hits that is very hard and strong, then an elastic collision could happen, and yes, very little damage to the object (that was hit) would occur.  But that would take a lot of material that was very strong. Like a pillar of concrete or a 1/2" metal plate. Most helmets or armor were not that thick.  So, for a normal 1mm thick plate of steel, I would stick with my answer of hard being better. And even a rusty ball with a spike would be better than a rustyball alone.

HOwever, put the rock or a rustyball against a person with a 1/2" thick helmet on that wouldn't deform, the rustyball would do better, because maybe you can shock their neck with all of the energy being transferred as opposed to the rock elastically bouncing off and not transferring as much energy.
Back to top
 

John R.
 
IP Logged
 
Sarosh
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline



Posts: 1233
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #18 - Apr 18th, 2023 at 3:17am
 
It's the acceleration that kills. I say a helmet shot with a sling has a higher chance of getting a KO than an arrow.
But it's more probable to get an arrow to the eye at close distances than a good helmet sling shot (maybe I'm wrong).
At long distances where getting an eye shot with an arrow is impossible because the angle doesnt allow it, the sling is better because of the higher momentum.
Tungsten spike with lead is better than tungsten spike with rusty ball, just because of the same momentum but lower time to transfer the energy.
Hard materials will get higher peak force which is higher acceleration and more chances of trauma.

Knights wear padding to protect from the higher acceleration so while he is protected from above, a bounced stone to the teeth can be more effective.
Back to top
 

Inactive I won't see PMs
 
IP Logged
 
StaffSlinger
Senior Member
****
Offline


Slinging Rocks!

Posts: 479
Florida
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #19 - Apr 18th, 2023 at 8:36am
 
Back in the Olde Days I did  a bunch of firearms ballistics -- damage at target and all that.  What matters most to the target is the total energy transferred to it completely.
Say you shoot a deer at range X.  At that range you want all of the bullet's energy transferred to the critter, leaving the bullet in the center of the mass (or at least not exiting the far side).

In arrow impacts, the bodkin points used against solid armored opponents were always tipped by a drop of wax.  The millisecond hesitation caused by the 'sticking' of the wax allowed the needle point to penetrate rather than skipping off the surface.
Back to top
 

CUM FUNDA PROSCRIPTAE ERUNT TUM SOLI PROSCRIPTI FUNDA HABEBUNT &&
StaffSlinger  
IP Logged
 
Sarosh
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline



Posts: 1233
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #20 - Apr 18th, 2023 at 11:32am
 
StaffSlinger wrote on Apr 18th, 2023 at 8:36am:
In arrow impacts, the bodkin points used against solid armored opponents were always tipped by a drop of wax.  The millisecond hesitation caused by the 'sticking' of the wax allowed the needle point to penetrate rather than skipping off the surface.


From what I know by drilling holes on metal, it is better to use oil than drilling dry. I havent read a detailed scientific explanation for this but i've read its heat dissipation which prevents the drill bit from becoming dull. I think something similar happens on the arrow tips instead of the stickiness of the wax, further penetration would be due to the wax acting as lubricant.

Back to top
 

Inactive I won't see PMs
 
IP Logged
 
Mersa
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline


Druid

Posts: 2673
Australia
Gender: male
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #21 - Apr 18th, 2023 at 6:23pm
 
Super interesting. Never thought about having a lubricant on an arrow but it makes sense, also the wax.
Back to top
 

Razor glandes, Aim for the eyes!!!
 
IP Logged
 
IronGoober
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline


...and now, No. 1, the
larch...

Posts: 2011
California
Gender: male
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #22 - Apr 18th, 2023 at 7:07pm
 
StaffSlinger wrote on Apr 18th, 2023 at 8:36am:
Back in the Olde Days I did  a bunch of firearms ballistics -- damage at target and all that.  What matters most to the target is the total energy transferred to it completely.
Say you shoot a deer at range X.  At that range you want all of the bullet's energy transferred to the critter, leaving the bullet in the center of the mass (or at least not exiting the far side).

In arrow impacts, the bodkin points used against solid armored opponents were always tipped by a drop of wax.  The millisecond hesitation caused by the 'sticking' of the wax allowed the needle point to penetrate rather than skipping off the surface. 

For something that completely penetrates and is able to easily deposit the energy in a localized manner because it can penetrate (i.e. bullets) this makes sense (i.e. that total energy deposited is the major factor correlating to damage). However, for something that will likely not penetrate and spreads its force out in a less localized manner, things get more complicated with more factors contributing to the final result. At least that is my interpretation/opinion, I do not have irrefutable evidence to back this up, just a lot of empirical data from my own experimentation.
Back to top
 

John R.
 
IP Logged
 
SerKraus
Senior Member
****
Offline


Slinging Rocks!

Posts: 266
Gender: male
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #23 - Apr 20th, 2023 at 7:57pm
 
I think anyone that believes a sling projectile will be negated by a helmet (a useless term when the type of helmet isn't specified) has never used or been around them. Often, people who denigrate the sling's lethality don't even know how they work, or have never been exposed to a truly proficient user.
Back to top
 

No citizen has a right to be an amateur in the matter of physical training…what a disgrace it is for a man to grow old without ever seeing the beauty and strength of which his body is capable. -Socrates
 
IP Logged
 
joe_meadmaker
Slinging.org Administrator
*****
Offline


Slinging Ice is Cool!

Posts: 3991
PA, USA
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #24 - Apr 20th, 2023 at 10:30pm
 
SerKraus wrote on Apr 20th, 2023 at 7:57pm:
helmet (a useless term when the type of helmet isn't specified)

Agreed.  And I think the exact same statement could be made about the term "sling projectile".  Wink
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Morphy
Forum Moderation
*****
Offline


Checkmate

Posts: 8239
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #25 - Jul 1st, 2023 at 1:16pm
 
Objectively speaking yes it is. There's a big caveat to that statement though.

Ill start with the good here- Yes it is good in regards to both questions, as a weapon and against armor.

The reason we can say this is true is because this is a case where we can work backwards. We know its good because it was used for thousands of years. Both as a weapon in general and against armored opponents in battle. If it continued to be used for that long it was effective. We dont even have to prove why. You dont use a weapon where your life is on the line if it isnt effective. Since it continued to be used we can start with the conclusion and then endeavor to work backwards to understand why. The armor question is a good one but I wont go into theories as to what ways it might have been effective in this post.

Now the bad- If you try to use this weapon to hunt with in a survival situation you will starve. This is coming from a sling fanatic. Im not hating its just true. There may be a few here that wouldnt but in general its a rather extreme diet plan.

I think I understand why it was used though. Aside from the obvious that people in the past grew up using it in a culture of sling masters and had more time and incentive to practice, I think the other reason is it allows for an alternative to using expensive ammo like arrows where the arrows might be broken or lost on a missed shot. I lived in such an area for a few years and it becomes immediately obvious when you shoot handmade arrows in such an enviorment why the incentive to take a shot with a sling is such a benefit. A good set of arrows are very labor intensive. Ive made many shoot arrows and cutting, curing, straitening, culling, sizing, spining, culling more, points etc means each perfect arrow can require maybe half a days work. This comes from the amount of arrows that dont make the cut. Whereas you can easily break one in a second. So the option of using a less expensive ammo on shots becomes a big bonus.

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Jaegoor
Interfector Viris Spurii
*****
Offline


Slinging Rocks!

Posts: 2862
Gender: male
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #26 - Jul 1st, 2023 at 4:31pm
 
Any weapon is as good as the person wielding the weapon.I could survive with a sling.
Back to top
 

Bono Mellius
 
IP Logged
 
Slyngorm
Funditor
****
Offline


Slingit...

Posts: 508
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #27 - Jul 2nd, 2023 at 3:36pm
 
Rat Man wrote on Apr 10th, 2023 at 8:39am:
or a long time the sling outdistanced the bow and arrow... up until the 15th century I believe.   

Not quite unfortunately. At the very least some flight bows outperform the sling in distance.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Archaic Arms
Funditor
****
Offline


Testing and inventing
"Archaic" weapons.

Posts: 786
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #28 - Jul 2nd, 2023 at 3:50pm
 
Slyngorm wrote on Jul 2nd, 2023 at 3:36pm:
Not quite unfortunately. At the very least some flight bows outperform the sling in distance.

The problem is that we don't actually know what ranges professional slingers were getting back in the day, thus the only thing we've got to go off are the few historical accounts that state the sling's outranging capability. I suspect that the maximum range was comparable to flight arrows, but effective range is of course, less.
Back to top
 

Regards,
Lewis
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Slyngorm
Funditor
****
Offline


Slingit...

Posts: 508
Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others?
Reply #29 - Jul 5th, 2023 at 3:07pm
 
Just realised, that talking about the sling as a weapon we can leave flight bows entirely out of the discussion.
So the sling still got that one. Grin
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 4 
Send Topic Print
(Moderators: Morphy, vetryan15, Rat Man, joe_meadmaker, Curious Aardvark, Kick, Chris)