This was a really great year. A lot of familiar faces and a lot of new ones. Great to see everyone!
@irgendeinekiwi - That's a good list. I can provide some response based on previous years and other information that's come to me.
- a group of volunteers sets up each comp after breakfast, before everyone else arrives and chitchats for 2 hours. As soon as everyone is there, we start.
This kind of exists. Pep has people who help out (like Carlos). The big standout this year was the setup in the park on Sunday. One thing to keep in mind is that location hasn't been used like that before. We've never had more than one or two targets there, and it has only for practice tournaments. I don't think it was realized how long the setup would take or it would have been started earlier.
- Nets, targets etc are all stored in one place and collected by setup crew.
Similar to the first point, I think this is how things are already supposed to be happening in theory. Regarding a setup crew, I don't think that should include competitors. If getting setup on time requires volunteers (who came to compete), the plan needs to be changed. That said, if they want to call in for volunteers to help to speed things up, I have zero issue with that. But I still think getting the needed equipment to a location shouldn't have any reliance on people coming in from out of country.
- Particiants + teams are divided up into 3 even groups, 1 per target
One group will always be different because it's the women and kids group. Other than that, I agree. The groups at each target should be the same size. I don't know why the different sizes other than when they listed the slingers, one group included the partial page of guys at the end of the list. So I think the difference in group sizes was just due to how things ended up when they wrote everyone's name down.
- Judges should all enforce same rules/standards. If necessary, participants can also judge.
I do believe that everyone is trying to, even if the results come out different. It's never going to be perfect. I think a judge on each side would help. But then you need to worry about noise because they obviously need to be able to communicate with each other. So is it worth it to tell everyone they need to shut up when near the slinging area? Also if the judges don't agree on a hit, can they stop the slinger to discuss?
I'm not in favor of participants judging. I don't think any of us would intentionally call something wrong. But I don't think that opportunity should even exists as an option.
- Digital scoring entry + liveview. I developed something for Pep a few months ago, but he went silent at some point.
Pep's number did change. That might be why communication dropped off. Digital scoring would definitely speed up a lot of things. I don't see it happening though.
- TB comp at the sports field where we were on wednesday.
Historically the tennis ball competition moves around. It's been in several locations since I was first there. The stones competition (and sometimes TB has always been at the archery club (Club de Tir Amb Arc Es Cubells). It's really a fantastic location. I'm not sure what happened with it this year. Sant Josep is used every year for stones practice, but this year was the first I've seen it used for the actual World Cup rounds.
- Evening meetings start within 30mins of announced time, if they don't then free time.
I totally understand this. But the meetings aren't mandatory. You can skip them if you want.
- Information should be updated in the whatsapp group daily
Yep, communication should be much more prompt and thorough. Even if it's only an update saying they're still figuring things out. And this again I don't think should be reliant on competitors to do.
- Info package provided to every participant at the start- number for whatsapp group, program, other contacts, meal times etc. English & Spanish.
100% agree! I think there's stuff regarding the schedule which does get figured out or changed on the fly. But a basic rundown of stuff (subject to change), how to communicate with people, rules, etc. should be sent to everyone. Especially new folks. I think after being there once people have a pretty good idea of how things work.
- Teams could be decided/organised earlier in the week, not night before.
This was a little unorganized because it was figure out at the last minute after Pep talked to some of us about how to do it. The way teams were put together and used this year was brand new. If it's done again (which I think it should be), it should be a little smoother the next time around. One change I would make is grouping together countries that only have one representative. I know Pep was asked about that this year and said no, but I don't agree.
- Some kind of basic regulations regarding slings (looking at you, Seņor Helicopter)
This is very unlikely. There's a big history about this type of thing. One of the reasons Pep is split off from the other Balearic competition in Spain is because he wants slingers to be able to use whatever they sling they choose (not just slings that meet traditional Balearic standards). I realize that you're not talking about making everyone use a Balearic sling. But even if restrictions are more open, it would need to be figured out what they are and how they'll be enforced. And what happens to the guy who shows up with a sling and they say no because it has something that wasn't thought of when the restrictions were created. I don't think G's problem is his sling so much as how he uses it. But Pep is also very much in favor of slingers using whatever style they want. I imagine there's a way to put certain restrictions on for safety. But I don't know what something like that would look like to restrict someone who is slinging dangerously vs. someone who's not. That's a hard thing to put in writing and remove subjectivity.