LightSlinger wrote on Feb 4
th, 2013 at 1:20am:
Nope. That doesn't really match the intent of the Historical awards.. But, that's not your fault. It's mine.
I'm obviously going to have to rewrite the requirements for this particular achievement before we move on with it... I think that what I will do is this: I will do some research as if I were trying for the different Historian levels, post something that does match the intent of the requirements, and then re-write the requirements from there..
Seriously Caldou, I'm really glad to have you onboard troubleshooting the system for me. Sometimes it's really hard to see these kind of problems while you're in the midst of writing these. I caught some of them myself, but mostly I've only been made aware of problems by others like yourself.
Again, thanks man! I appreciate it!
Well, would you have said that it matched, I would have refused ^^ Just finding 2 youtube video, even not posted here just for the petition should not make the cut ^^
It could be time-free but you still need like 3 - 5 - 7 sources, either commented or with some context. It could also be identifying some "mystery source" that someone else posted.
(If I agree on the fact that the tutorial I linked could never be a source, even for modern times, I think that the palestinian slinging, with a good comment and contextualisation could be a valid one. Of course, as I posted it it would be largely missing the mark
)
For the difficulty scale, you may want to ask Thearos, he is more qualified than me ^^
But I don't think imposing times periods as a difficulty criteria is fair : I was involved with a reenactment group, from the Gaulish Antiquity, so I researched material for this time period and not for more recent times, like the last 1000 years (yes, 3 differents 0, not a typo). But since I'm not really interested in C17, 18 and 19th, I would never be able to pass the first level...
On another, larger note : I find the additionnal requirements for Artifex easier to achieve thant the lvl 1 Research (with the exception of the lucky factor for Archeologist 1 & 2) : with a little effort I could gain 2 more lvl 3... while the Research need some more serious dedication.