Knaight wrote on Jul 9
th, 2010 at 5:19pm:
John wrote on Jul 9
th, 2010 at 9:21am:
Aussie wrote on Jul 9
th, 2010 at 8:07am:
Of course I'm talking about unmodified dry regulation tennis balls with a normal amount of fuzzy felt, level ground and no wind advantage. They just seem to lose speed so rapidly that no matter how hard I sling 100 m seems unattainable. It's not that I can't ever sling 100 m, fairly easy with a golf ball or a stone. I just can't do it with a tennis ball and I'm wondering if anybody else can. According to Matthias simulator 52 m/s at 45 degrees will do it. Perhaps that figure is wrong?
Silly question, but assuming youre using one of your seatbelt slings... its pretty light, youre using a relatively large, unaerodynamic projectile that is also light...... it it possible that the drag of the ball while in the sling is actually making it harder for you to reach a velocity that you could normally reach with a more dense or heavy projectile - espcially since youre probably using a style that relies on relatively rapid acceleration(assuming your normal figure 8). You certainly pointed out to me at one point the way a pouch changes the diameter of its rotation if you try to accelerate it too fast - could that be whats happening here? And the faster you are trying to throw - the more pronounced its getting - largely wasting your extra effort? Maybe try a heavier pouch, or a helicopter or balaeric style that gives you more time to get the ball up to speed?
That probably is very relevant, I lost a lot of tennis ball range when I started using an extremely thin sling, now that I'm back to a thicker one with a far heavier pouch tennis ball range is back within acceptable parameters. Still 95 m on the high end, and as low as 60 m on the low end, but acceptable.
Guys,
The points you make are valid. Whether the sling is seatbelt or Aussie style, it still is quite light. Perhaps I can have the best of both worlds by making a special sling with a weighted pouch and ultrathin cords so as to get the heavier feel and still minimize air drag? In the past I have been against weighting pouches because it actually wastes energy accelerating the pouch. It is much more efficient to merely increase the weight of the projectile. But as I have a fixed weight in this case unless I modify the ball which I don't want to do it may work. Ergonomically the overall package may be less efficient but the effect should be to get that ball moving faster.
Using the Audacity sound recording method I have measured my max. slinging speed at a whisker under 55 m/s but that was with a 75 gram rubber cylinder. A tennis ball weighs only 55 grams.
The simulator I was referring to is something created by Matthias who is no longer on the site. It included all sorts of variables including air drag. Without it all balls, in fact any projectile, would perform equally well with 100 m attainable at a release velocity of only 32 m/s.
Still there must be someone out there who can do it in the real world. Mrboss claims 1100 ft with his long sling pirouette and a 5 oz stone; all I want is one third that distance with a tennis ball.
The challenge is out to all!!!!
Aussie