Sarosh wrote on Feb 13
th, 2024 at 7:10am:
Dieter Beller wrote on Feb 13
th, 2024 at 4:44am:
Does somebody know, why some former slingers (for exempale the balears) wrapped rsp bolster theire left arm?
probably as a shield. a last moment "I can't avoid the shot" sacrifice of the left arm over vitals or legs.
slingers would be more dispersed and they'd probably prefer avoiding shots instead of using a shield all the time.
hanging leather or thick cloth would be a good way to stop some incoming shots.
I think I've seen shields with thick ropes hanging on the lower end to protect the legs from slingstones. probably from pacific islands but I dont remember any source.
Interesting thoughts ....
Clearly battle tactics vary by culture and experience but the reconstruction at Burnswark shows the romans came in and used uphill sling barrage from behind purpose built earth mounds.
Joe MM in his videos did some tests of shield versus sling (what fun 😁) but in his video of Lecuyer (greek ) style slinging he "wore" a towel over his left arm to mimic the picture.
He speculated over use but I'm not aware of any firm conclusions.
Perhaps current sling users/researchers in places like India,Tibet and Guam may have strong views but I think it would take a doctoral dissertation or research fellowship to chase that one up.
We may have to wait for further written evidence to be recovered to find out why slingers in different arenas covered their non dominant arm.
Discuss.
👍
😁