Nightweave,
When you are using a narrow grip, which cord is closer to your fingertip? The release cord, or the retained cord? If you have the retained cord closer to your fingertip, you will be more likely to put a top-spin on the rock. If you have the release cord closer to your fingertip, you will be more likely to put a back-spin on the rock. When I first tried a narrow grip, I held it the first way, with the retained cord closer to fingertip. Reversing the grip, produced an immediate improvement in my slinging.
It is not just your style and your ammo, that interact with your grip. It is also your sling. A sling with a long pouch can be used with wide or narrow grips; a sling with a short pouch will lose its load when used with a wide grip. I have a sling designed specifically for golf balls with a pouch 3.5 inches long (about three-quarters of a golf ball's circumference); with a a wide grip, the ball falls out somewhere during my swing. I have another sling designed for anything; the pouch is seven inches long, and golf balls or small rocks just roll back and forth during my windup if I am using a wide grip.
I started with a wide grip (finger loop on ring finger), and the Greek styles as depicted by David Taylor. I continued using wide grip when I was learning the Figure-8, but switched to narrow grip when I was learning the Apache style. I tried the narrow grip with the Figure-8 when Nwmanitou showed us
how he holds a sling
and I found that it worked. This is also when I changed my grip so that the release cord was closer to my fingertip, as nwmanitou holds it.
I have less control of spin with a narrow grip, but it is not NO control. With heavy or stiff cords and the Apache style, I can spin a rock any way I want (most of the time). What I mean is, when it spins wrong, it is because I slung it wrong, not because the sling twisted in a way I could not anticipate. Thn, flexible cords, on the other hand, are uncontrollable as far as spin goes: the rock spins however it spins. Those slings I have to use with a wide grip, if I want any control.
Yesterday I was slinging acorns, and I was able to put a nice football spin on some of them. Narrow grip, figure-8 and underhand styles. Those I slung point first, I could see the cap all the way out; those I slung cap first, I could see the nut all the way out; those where I goofed and put a side-spin on it, I could see the whole acorn spinning like a top as it sliced off to the left. The spin controlled the orientation, not the weight distribution.