Quote:bake for the same ammount of time
Yeah, 30-40 minutes @ 325 F is way too short a time for them to turn rock hard. I leave them in the oven until I go to bed. So I bake them about 2-3 hours.
By the way, I just put the next batch in the oven. I made most of these much smaller than the last batch. They're about 5/4 the size of a glof ball (for those of you who don't like math, that's one golf ball plus a quarter of a golf ball

). I think this batch will turn out much better. I only had 1/4 cup of salt left, so I used a little extra flour to make up for the missing salt. I actually kneaded this batch. Another useful tip is add a bunch of flour to the surface you'll be kneading on and add some to your hands. It was a pain trying to peel off wet flour from my hands, especially because it was all over both hands... I just keep learning