Slinging.org Forum
https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl
General >> General Slinging Discussion >> Slings Vs Armor
https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1615673441

Message started by Morphy on Mar 13th, 2021 at 5:10pm

Title: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 13th, 2021 at 5:10pm
You knew this was coming.  ;D

What do you think?

Brigadine
https://youtu.be/DCf-CnjbWcg

Gambeson
https://youtu.be/fzWipvLiCjY

Hardened Leather
https://youtu.be/RO_nG6OpCKg

Scale
https://youtu.be/kavPt1CEJWs


Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Hirtius on Mar 13th, 2021 at 5:50pm
Finally, a safe topic that everyone will agree on. What could possibly go wrong?  ;)


Keep in mind the armors used in those videos might not be representative of actuality, especially the organic armors because they aren't Tod's specialty. The gambeson especially is too thin and using worse quality than what would have been used historically. I don't think many sling stones or bullets will do too much damage through a well made gambeson. I feel like most well made armors would dissipate much of the force of a sling stone or bullet, even if they did get dented. I feel like hardened leather would be the exception, as I'm not sure how good it is at absorbing impacts.

As we all know, aim for the head. Even if they have a helmet, you still might be able to ruin someone's day (or life).

But, I think we definitely need testing.

We'll have to have someone wear the armor. Don't worry, you'll probably be safe. Probably. Any volunteers?

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Jaegoor on Mar 13th, 2021 at 6:07pm
https://youtu.be/mMMebwEdAaE

At the end of the video there is a shot at a Roman bowl.  I've already destroyed several helmets.  From antiquity to the late Middle Ages.  A head hit turns you off the light.  The center of my Diane is made of 8mm steel.  I keep shooting this plate to the wok.  Hitting body armor is extremely painful.  To break bones.  Organs suspend.  Morphy already said a lot about it

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by SerKraus on Mar 13th, 2021 at 6:43pm
Technically, the stone doesn't even have to damage the armor to wound the combatant.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Josephusflav on Mar 13th, 2021 at 8:43pm
i SLUNG A STONE A DISABLED A ABRAMS TURRET

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Jaegoor on Mar 14th, 2021 at 2:54am
That reminds me of an event in the panzermuseeum Munster.  Military history was shown there.  From the Bronze Age to World War II.  The tanks were of course a special attraction.  These were shown in full action at a show.  On an outside site.  In the evening the tanks were driven back into the hall.  We took a joke.  There was a Greek hoplite.  He stood with his shield and a lance on the way and blocked a Panther D. He called out loud ..... You can't pass here.  The tank commander looked out of his turret from above.  He laughed out loud at the joke.  He replied ... How are you going to stop me?  Our hoplite answered again.  I don't, but we have a slinger.  That was my cue.  I stood about 15m behind the tank.  The panther d has a hatch at the back of the tower.  This was open.  So I shot him a tennis ball and shouted out loud ... HANDGRENADE.  The ball actually hit and jumped around in the tank.  Everyone thought it was funny.  It was quite a gag.  Only the commandant didn't laugh.  He was very angry.  He later complained to the management.  But there you saw it loosely and thought it was a funny idea to depict different time epochs.  But the tank fans didn't want that.  It would be dubious.  That's true.  But it was also very funny 😁

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 14th, 2021 at 5:11am
Had a patient yesterday from a head on motor vehicle collision. Not a spot on her but was in shock and decompensating quickly. Wearing a shoulder and lap belt with air bags deployed. She looked pristine on the outside but something was seriously wrong on the inside. I would take an airbag over gambeson any day of the week but that can’t dissipate the shock associated with severe blunt force trauma. Base on this and many other experiences I must conclude that the sling is a child’s toy and incapable of real damage against protected individuals. 

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Hirtius on Mar 14th, 2021 at 5:10pm

Morphy wrote on Mar 14th, 2021 at 5:11am:
Had a patient yesterday from a head on motor vehicle collision. Not a spot on her but was in shock and decompensating quickly. Wearing a shoulder and lap belt with air bags deployed. She looked pristine on the outside but something was seriously wrong on the inside. I would take an airbag over gambeson any day of the week but that can’t dissipate the shock associated with severe blunt force trauma. Base on this and many other experiences I must conclude that the sling is a child’s toy and incapable of real damage against protected individuals. 


Yeah, I don't think a gambeson will do much for anyone in a head-on car crash. But keep in mind that a sling stone is far less energy and momentum than that, and concentrates it on a certain area. Maybe if the area affected is the head or neck, the padding isn't going to save anyone from the shock and momentum. But a gambeson on the torso? I'm not so sure how great the damage will be. It probably depends on how thick it is. Unfortunately it hasn't been tested. I don't think impact of gambesons on blunt damage has been tested for any other weapons either.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 14th, 2021 at 5:28pm
It does depend on how thick it is. You are correct. Total energy by itself though is irrelevant. A freight train bumping into you at 5 miles an hour has more energy than a hundred fatal car crashes and will not even leave a bruise.

The point Im making is not to compare energy but that penetration or the lack thereof should never even enter this conversation. But in many peoples minds it seems to be one of the big indicators of lethality. Neither is the amount of damage shown on the outside an indicator of anything at all.


Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Jaegoor on Mar 14th, 2021 at 6:07pm
They have little experience.  We used the sling in reenactor fighting.  Ammunition are water balloons.  These burst on impact and distribute their weight very quickly.  A friend was hit on the helmet.  He was passed out for 20 minutes.  Another was hit right in the chest.  He wore Norman armor.  A vest.  A gambeson and over it a chain shirt.  He had a black bruise from the hit.  And there were individual imprints of the chain links on the edge.  He was in shock and needed medical attention.  It was just a balloon with water.  A stone would have broken his ribs.  The injury would have been much worse.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 14th, 2021 at 7:01pm

Jaegoor wrote on Mar 14th, 2021 at 6:07pm:
They have little experience.  We used the sling in reenactor fighting.  Ammunition are water balloons.  These burst on impact and distribute their weight very quickly.  A friend was hit on the helmet.  He was passed out for 20 minutes.  Another was hit right in the chest.  He wore Norman armor.  A vest.  A gambeson and over it a chain shirt.  He had a black bruise from the hit.  And there were individual imprints of the chain links on the edge.  He was in shock and needed medical attention.  It was just a balloon with water.  A stone would have broken his ribs.  The injury would have been much worse.


I have a feeling that until people see this kind of trauma for themselves they wont be able to believe it. You and I have different backgrounds but where they intersect is our experience seeing how fragile a person can be. Pro wrestling videos aside.  ::) ::) ::)

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by TheHMGSlingingRep on Mar 15th, 2021 at 7:18am

Jaegoor wrote on Mar 14th, 2021 at 6:07pm:
They have little experience.  We used the sling in reenactor fighting.  Ammunition are water balloons.  These burst on impact and distribute their weight very quickly.  A friend was hit on the helmet.  He was passed out for 20 minutes.  Another was hit right in the chest.  He wore Norman armor.  A vest.  A gambeson and over it a chain shirt.  He had a black bruise from the hit.  And there were individual imprints of the chain links on the edge.  He was in shock and needed medical attention.  It was just a balloon with water.  A stone would have broken his ribs.  The injury would have been much worse.


I must say I agree. I do larp and have been shot with a foam tipped arrow in the chest, just bellow the ribs and I most definitely felt that. And we were slinging tennis balls against someone holding a shield and you definitely feel at least some impact. If the projectile in any of the instances was a stone or glande, then I'm pretty certain that the result would not have been pretty.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Jaegoor on Mar 15th, 2021 at 8:16am
Yes, that's absolutely true.  I was in Hastings.  There was a great reenactor battle there.  Archers use rubber blunt tips there.  It is normally used to hunt birds or rabbits.  There was a lot of pain.  😁

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Kick on Mar 15th, 2021 at 4:58pm
In some ways it's a good thing people have trouble envisioning what being hit with a sling stone would be like... But yeah I think I fall more on the side of what Morphy and Jaegoor are saying. I really don't think a gambeson would save someone from a well placed sling stone to the chest.

I've talked about it before but I think lethality is overstated in battles. You don't have to kill everyone on the other side to win. Just getting winded, even for 5 minutes, could be pretty decisive for you on the battlefield.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by CatHataFish on Mar 16th, 2021 at 1:20am
Good idea, in.  Maybe if we bother Joerg Sprave enough, he'll do it.  I think it may be easier using high-powered modern slingshot that can consistently replicate the velocities of a skilled slinger around here, but maybe only if biconicals were not used.  I imagine you'd need an actual sling to get them spinning.  Or would not be too much of an affront to the slinging tradition to use a machine?  It would have the advantage of a consistent and easily duplicatable speed.


Jaegoor wrote on Mar 14th, 2021 at 6:07pm:
They have little experience.  We used the sling in reenactor fighting.  Ammunition are water balloons.  These burst on impact and distribute their weight very quickly.  A friend was hit on the helmet.  He was passed out for 20 minutes.  Another was hit right in the chest.  He wore Norman armor.  A vest.  A gambeson and over it a chain shirt.  He had a black bruise from the hit.  And there were individual imprints of the chain links on the edge.  He was in shock and needed medical attention.  It was just a balloon with water.  A stone would have broken his ribs.  The injury would have been much worse.

So you regularly have reenactment mock battles where the ammunition knocks people out or sends them to the hospital?

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 16th, 2021 at 1:26am

Kick wrote on Mar 15th, 2021 at 4:58pm:
In some ways it's a good thing people have trouble envisioning what being hit with a sling stone would be like... But yeah I think I fall more on the side of what Morphy and Jaegoor are saying. I really don't think a gambeson would save someone from a well placed sling stone to the chest.

I've talked about it before but I think lethality is overstated in battles. You don't have to kill everyone on the other side to win. Just getting winded, even for 5 minutes, could be pretty decisive for you on the battlefield.


I suspect some of us sling much smaller stones than others. If all one has ever slung is small limestone crushed rock it’s hard to envision what 1.5 pounds of granite would do at high speed. For those of us who have slung larger stones there’s no question what it would do to a guy in brigadine.  ;)

Actually I would like to see what Joe could do with a 1 to 1.5 pound stone. He was slinging those ice blocks that were close to 4 pounds pretty well. I bet he could get some serious damage from “smaller” stones. Smaller as in the size of two large fists put together.  ;D ::)

You hear that Joe, you are being volunteered. Karma I think for the egg challenge.  ;D

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Kick on Mar 16th, 2021 at 3:34am
That's true. Almost all the stones I've ever slung have been Finnish granite. I've only ever broken two stones. One was at the International, so much lighter softer stone, and one that wasn't granite I found over here. It was already cracked and some sort of slate like material. The granite ones just don't break.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Jaegoor on Mar 16th, 2021 at 3:57am
There is a red granite here on the Baltic Sea.  He's probably from Norway.  I also call him blood stone.  These stones hardly ever break.  Maybe one in two or three years.  When they break they look like they're bleeding.  From a geological point of view, these stones are very, very old.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Albion Slinger on Mar 17th, 2021 at 3:05pm
Found this passage that Slingbadger shared a few years ago.
Diodoros of Sicily, writing in the 1st cent. BC gives an account of the missiles at the Battle pf Ekonomos.
Book XIX-- "but when Hamilcar saw that his men were being overpowered. he brought up the slingers, who came from the Balearic islands, and numbered at least 1000. By hurling a shower of stones, they wounded men and even killed not a few who they were attacking, and shattered the defensive armor of most of them. For the men were accustomed to sling stones weighing a mina (1.25 lbs) contribute a great deal to victory in battle"

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 17th, 2021 at 3:15pm
^Yep

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by joe_meadmaker on Mar 17th, 2021 at 3:48pm

Morphy wrote on Mar 16th, 2021 at 1:26am:
You hear that Joe, you are being volunteered. Karma I think for the egg challenge. 

I guess I don't know how karma works. ;)

I've actually got an idea of something I can try with a big rock.  As of now they're predicting a pretty nice weekend.  I'll see if I can do a couple experiments.
Even if it doesn't make much of a video, smashing stuff with a big rock should be good for venting frustration if I'm not able to hit a playing card out of a hourglass.  :)

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by IronGoober on Mar 17th, 2021 at 4:17pm
Just be sure the Karma doesn't do this to you...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcBF3Y3fJL4

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Morphy on Mar 17th, 2021 at 4:54pm

joe_meadmaker wrote on Mar 17th, 2021 at 3:48pm:

Morphy wrote on Mar 16th, 2021 at 1:26am:
You hear that Joe, you are being volunteered. Karma I think for the egg challenge. 

I guess I don't know how karma works. ;)

I've actually got an idea of something I can try with a big rock.  As of now they're predicting a pretty nice weekend.  I'll see if I can do a couple experiments.
Even if it doesn't make much of a video, smashing stuff with a big rock should be good for venting frustration if I'm not able to hit a playing card out of a hourglass.  :)


Dont worry this is good karma!


joe_meadmaker wrote on Mar 9th, 2021 at 12:15pm:
And to others too, it should be said, throwing your egg into the air is in no way required.  :)
Except Morphy.  He has to.  ;)  :D


Luckily I think Channing beat me to the whole egg against egg shot. Maybe I can just try Greek. Also want to try smashing things with my large sling as well. For me if a 1.5 pound stone was possible I think a 10-12 oz stone should have some good zip and still hit quite hard. Looking forward to the video bro.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by Kick on Mar 18th, 2021 at 1:54am

IronGoober wrote on Mar 17th, 2021 at 4:17pm:
Just sure the Karma doesn't do this to you...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcBF3Y3fJL4

I gotta say that ain't a bad looking sling for a parody.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by TheJackinati on Mar 18th, 2021 at 1:49pm

Hirtius wrote on Mar 13th, 2021 at 5:50pm:
Keep in mind the armors used in those videos might not be representative of actuality, especially the organic armors because they aren't Tod's specialty. The gambeson especially is too thin and using worse quality than what would have been used historically.


What Todd is showing in that video is not particularly representative of a gambeson IMHO.

It is, however, very representative of a "Padded Jack", a Standalone armour that was largely designed to be worn by itself. The telling detail is when Todd mentions 32 layers of linen. That is too thick to be viably worn with other armour (Unless perhaps you were using very thin linen). Not only that, I have a vague suspicion I know what his source is.

The subject of medieval textile armours is a difficult one... but I'll roughly try to break things down. When it comes to the High/Late Medieval period in Western Europe... there were largely 'Four' types of textile armours. Three of them emerged at about the 1100's. The fourth and final emerged at about the middle of the 14th century... and can barely be considered armour. I'll explain the first three.

From the literary sources of the period, 'Gambesons' started being worn around the 1100's and into later periods, but they were originally not worn under armour, but over an armour, particularly over hauberks, and were generally made either from as much as ~15 layers of linen/nettle/hemp etc, though it wouldn't surprise me if wool batting was used as well. Often these gambesons were made without sleeves (Such as is described in the Kings Mirror of Norway)

As this over-armour gambeson was coming about, There was also a lighter version of armour that was beginning to emerge as well, known as the Aketon. This is much slimmer than the gambeson, perhaps only made from 4-7 layers of linen, or a mix of linen + batting (Which gives a hint as to how the name of the garment in question emerged)... These aketon's could be worn over a Tunic and below a hauberk.

Then you have Padded Jacks. Also likely originating in the same period as Gambesons, they would have very likely been made similar to how Todd describes them.

As you enter deeper into the 1300's, Aketons and Gambesons are largely being replaced over time by Arming doublets and the Coat-of-Plates respectively (An armour that itself originated from a Surcoat of plates... Surcotes being decorative garments worn over gambesons or hauberks).

This means that the further Into the 1300's, Padded Jacks were also colloquially referred to as "Gambesons"... even though the 'Gambesons' as an over-armour garment were well and truly dead (Except perhaps in the case of Jupons... I'm not going to explain that one.) also... which makes the subject very, very confusing.

So all in all, I don't really think that what Todd has shown is thin. In fact, Jacks were generally made to be about one finger thick. That is roughly in the 1cm territory... and it is very thick if one were to compare it to gambesons or aketons. Those were thinner than Jacks. Arming doublets were exceptionally thin. They would all perform very differently. I have the feeling Gambesons or Aketons would perform very badly...

But here's the kicker... You can potentially combine aketons and gambesons together and essentially end up with a similar configuration as a padded jack.

"And such persons are to be properly armed with two pieces; namely, with haketon and gambeson, or else with haketon and corset, or with haketon and plates."

Source: https://www.british-history.ac.uk/no-series/memorials-london-life/pp33-36#p16

And perhaps this is why the sources tend to state that Aketons should have sleeves but not for gambesons... It all becomes very, veeeeery interesting, because it would be impossible to combine the two if they both had sleeves.

Title: Re: Slings Vs Armor
Post by funditor on Mar 18th, 2021 at 2:37pm
I once did a test shot with a spherice 250g sandstone projectile with a balearic sling against a 1mm bronze plate (CuSn6 alloy) 30cm squared, fixed to a huge straw bale at roughly chest height from 10m distance. This should simulate a breast plate. A gelatine chest would be perhaps a better simulation, with PU ribs embedde to show trauma effect. The deformation of the plate was interestingly neglible, the dent was less than a centimeter deep. If the impact caused injury, it must be blunt trauma or tissue shock.

Slinging.org Forum » Powered by YaBB 2.5.2!
YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2026. All Rights Reserved.