Slinging.org Forum
https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl
General >> Other Primitive Weapons >> Bāton de Commandement
https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1332428825

Message started by Ahaw on Mar 22nd, 2012 at 11:07am

Title: Bāton de Commandement
Post by Ahaw on Mar 22nd, 2012 at 11:07am
Hi all,
While seeking some infos on the web about Atlatl/Woomera I found out about another weapon that is halfway between these and the sling.
Since this type of weapon has been mostly found in French archaeological sites, it is called by a French name : Bāton de Commandement, or Perforated Baton.
It is a small sized Atlatl (around 20cm... I let you do the convertion in inches, let's reverse the roles for once, hehe) with a handle and a larger head with a hole in it.
From what I understood, it is not proven that it was used as an atlatl-type weapon... but this guy Ehkahk made a replica with a bit of rope and it does apparently work well.

Ehkahk's version only has a small hole in it... but with a bigger hole like the one below, you can pass the spear through it in order to straighten it easily without using your teeth or legs.

The rope is rolled around the spear, giving it a spinning movement in the air... that might be the reason why Ehkahk says he doesn't need to fletch his spears/darts.
Conclusion : a very light and small weapon, multitool (spear straightener, could be used to make fire as Australian Aborigines did with their hardwood boomerangs, as a head-crusher, shovel, plate or even a bull-roarer), with some multi-purpose string on it too.
No need to bother carrying your spears too as you apparently just need to chop and point a thin trunk or bamboo and there you go !
... I'll definitively try to make one !

And I've also found this text which seems awesome (but in French) : Da Vinci's spear-throwers !

Cheers !

Edit : found out that DavidMorningstar already mentionned it & Paleoarts actually made one :

Please tell us more !

Edit 2 : Loving to combine different utilities in one same object, I've just tied a paracord rope to the handle of my camp knife.
When it's fixed in its sheath, the knife becomes a "bāton de commandement".
Been trying to throw a small diameter pvc pipe with it (only thing approx similar to a spear I had right now).
It works... but no power at all.
I'm guessing the pvc ain't a good spear... and maybe the paracord is too long as well.
In the next days, I'll try with some straight piece of wood and bamboo, and different sizes of cord.

Title: Re: Bāton de Commandement
Post by Liberty dog on Mar 22nd, 2012 at 9:28pm
sort of like a swiss arrow but with a handle...........very nice....let us know how it works.......im thinking i might give it a go if i can come up with some darts here in oregon......something natrual.
im new here so i dont know what woods are to be had in my area

Title: Re: Bāton de Commandement
Post by xxkid123 on Mar 22nd, 2012 at 10:11pm
It looks like a reverse mounted amentum on steroids.

Technical explanation of amentum: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amentum

Pics! http://www.armor.com/amentum.html

David Morningstar has used it before.

The way the cord unwraps around the handle allows the spear to spin, giving extra accuracy. Plus the leverage you get is pretty good.

Title: Re: Bāton de Commandement
Post by Bill Skinner on Mar 23rd, 2012 at 11:27am
The antler picture shown is a shaft straightner.  The Baton de Commandement that was used for throwing spears usually has a fork in the end to help support the weight of the shaft and reduce fatigue if the thrower has to freeze in position during a stalk.  According to some articles, it predates the atlatl by a long time, some say as much as 30,000 years and one accout said 50,000.  As I was researching something else, I didn't do any follow up, so those figures may be very incorrect.  And no, I didn't use Wikipedia.

Title: Re: Bāton de Commandement
Post by Atlatlista on Apr 5th, 2012 at 10:28pm
I'm looking forward to playing around with these, though I'm actually kind of skeptical that they're spear throwers.  There certainly isn't a lot of evidence in the archaeological record to support it, and the vibe I got from the first paper to champion the theory of batons as spear-throwers (Leon Underwood's 1965 paper Le baton de commandement) was that it was a polemic against classifying things as "symbolic" not necessarily proof that it was, in fact, a spearthrower.  And that paper's spearthrowers look wildly different from the swiss arrow model we see today.  That came out in an issue of Primitive Technology in an article penned by Paul Comstock, if I'm not mistaken.  Leon Underwood's initial models presumed significant damage to the artifacts, disguising an atlatl-like hook to propel the darts.

I'm not saying that they're definitely not spearthrowers, the whole thing just reminds me a little bit of this:


Title: Re: Bāton de Commandement
Post by perpetualstudent on Apr 6th, 2012 at 12:39pm
doesn't all archeology/anthropology?  :D ;D

I was actually thinking about this when I was working on the computer earlier today, in 5000 years if somebody found a keyboard, wouldn't it seem reasonable to dismiss our claimed typing speeds as "exaggerated"?




Slinging.org Forum » Powered by YaBB 2.5.2!
YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2026. All Rights Reserved.