| Slinging.org Forum | |
|
https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl
General >> General Slinging Discussion >> Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1681115910 Message started by Clover on Apr 10th, 2023 at 4:38am |
|
|
Title: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Clover on Apr 10th, 2023 at 4:38am
I don't know if this should go into the forum for other medieval weapons but how do you think slings compare to other weapons? I know it's impossible to say a weapon is objectively better than another (in most cases) because there are a million different factors like the skill needed, the strength needed and literally just everything. But I want to know the pros and cons of maybe a sling vs a longbow.
Another thing that I could use help with. How do slings fair well against armor? Whenever I bring up how I think slings are one of the best ranged weapons, people always counter with "if its against an unarmored opponent. But a helmet would easily counter a sling" or stuff like that. I do not believe armor is immediately impervious to a sling, but obviously I've never been in a situation involving slings and medieval armor. Also, how well would it fair compared to other ranged weapons against an armored opponent? All knowledge and opinions will be very appreciated. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Yfir on Apr 10th, 2023 at 4:55am
I'm not too knowledgeable when it comes to this stuff, but I do know that slings aren't to be trifled with. I've made significant dents in trees and concrete with a rock from my slings.
As for the helmets, again take this with a grain of salt because I'm in no way informed in this, but I really think a large rock or lead ball to the head at such a speed that a sling delivers would cause problems even for helmet wearers. At the very least it should stun them I'd imagine. One thing I can say for certain is that slings are much, much quicker to make than bows. You can make a simple sling in half an hour, a bow would take far longer and more training to make. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Mersa on Apr 10th, 2023 at 6:52am
The slings main advantage is the ability to throw random items, if you’re anywhere with rocks around that a great advantage already.
Also being easy to carry means it could easily be used in conjunction with other weapons. As for armour that really depends on the size and density of the ammunition you’re using. I doubt a helmet is gonna stop a direct blow from a large weight projectile. Best case scenario is it causes more ricocheting. Again there’s lots of scenarios where you could argue either way. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Rat Man on Apr 10th, 2023 at 8:39am
Welcome, Clover;
For a long time the sling outdistanced the bow and arrow... up until the 15th century I believe. The bow and arrow has a few advantages over the sling. First, the learning curve is much shorter. One can learn to use a bow and arrow effectively in one afternoon. The time it takes to become functional with a sling varies for each individual but it is much longer. Also the bow and arrow is much more accurate. The advantages of the sling are that it's easy to make and often your ammo is laying at your feet. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Apr 10th, 2023 at 9:19am
Most things have been covered very well. Some of the sling's advantages are that it's easy to make and carry. Ammunition can also be readily available. And a sling can outdistance a bow. It all comes down to the projectile and the person who's throwing/shooting it.
Regarding slings against armor, this is very similar to the question of whether an arrow can penetrate armor. It depends on many factors. The type of armor. The size, density, and shape of the projectile. Obviously the speed it's moving. Etc. There are some things to keep in mind though. A weapon like a bow and arrow is designed for penetration. When most people talk about an arrow vs. armor, they're talking about plate armor (because an arrow won't be stopped by mail, hardened leather, and things like that). When plate armor was becoming more common, weapons such as war hammers and maces also became more common. The reason is because blunt force is a better attack against plate where penetrating weapons don't work as well. Now a glande thrown from a sling can definitely penetrate, but a sling can also do blunt force very well. Larger sized stones thrown from a sling have incredible stopping power. Even if a stone is stopped by a shield, it's still very intimidating. I can attest to that because I've experienced it. I think a couple of the reasons for slings falling out of favor to weapons such as the bow is the difficulty to use, as Rat Man mentioned. And another thing is if you're going to fight somewhere that doesn't have stones lying around, you need to carry ammunition. And stones or glandes get heavy really quick. And last thing, if you haven't see it yet, one of our members (Slyngorm) did a great write-up of ranged weapons and comparing them. It's in the Other Primitive Weapons board but here's a link: https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1603626991. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by IronGoober on Apr 10th, 2023 at 12:20pm
Also, we have first-hand accounts of the sling being very effective against armored opponents. One of our members (Jaegoor) was in a re-enactment and saw a man get hit on hit head with a water balloon (who was wearing a replica metal helmet) and was completely knocked out cold. Imagine if it were more solid than a water balloon, the result would have been much more injurious.
Slings can impart a lot of damage even through armor, especially if the armor is pliable, like leather or mail. https://slinging.org/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1615673441/14 |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by NooneOfConsequence on Apr 13th, 2023 at 7:40am
We’re speaking in hypotheticals now, but a more solid object might be less effective than a water balloon because it’s more of an elastic rather than inelastic collision. There can be a huge difference in energy transfer. That’s also why rustyballs may be more dangerous than rocks.
…sounds like a good Joe Meadmaker experiment! |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Clover on Apr 13th, 2023 at 2:20pm NooneOfConsequence wrote on Apr 13th, 2023 at 7:40am:
Maybe get a watermelon and put a helmet on it. Then hit it with a sling to see what happens, I think it would be a fun experiment(blowing up watermelons always is). Though it wouldn't figure out how much it would hurt the neck of the opponent and might not figure out how badly it hurts the brain of the opponent. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Archaic Arms on Apr 13th, 2023 at 3:46pm
The type of ammo is a very significant factor when talking about sling vs armour.
Big stones can have an enormous amount of momentum, and if that lands a square hit on a helmet... That's definitely lights out. Basically the better the armour, the heavier you want your projectile. I believe big stones from a sling could potentially be a lot more dangerous to a knight in full plate than arrows from a warbow. As far as sling projectiles go, lead bullets are probably the most comparable to arrows (aside from kestros), but trade some penetration ability for more impact energy. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Apr 13th, 2023 at 4:49pm |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by StaffSlinger on Apr 13th, 2023 at 5:15pm
Yep -- that's more than enough to ruin your day.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Kordwar on Apr 13th, 2023 at 5:45pm
I would love to see someone use a metal helmet and attach some of those shock watch stickers the Mythbusters would use to the inside and see what the highest amount of Gs would pop
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Apr 13th, 2023 at 8:24pm NooneOfConsequence wrote on Apr 13th, 2023 at 7:40am:
I could totally work rusty balls into the video I'm going to do with all the glandes I got. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by IronGoober on Apr 14th, 2023 at 11:17am
Rustyballs against a pumpkin are pretty useless. https://youtu.be/T-fIUb-66zw?t=196
Stones will punch right through. A pumpkin is not a piece of steel for sure, but hard ammo is generally better than soft for damage, as there is higher peak force in the collision. Maybe soft can have higher energy transfer, but the peak force is lower as it is flattened out over a longer period of time. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by NooneOfConsequence on Apr 17th, 2023 at 12:14am
Ok, IG… now the plot thickens: how about a rusty ball with a tungsten spike in front? Is peak force still more important?
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Mersa on Apr 17th, 2023 at 3:36am
Oh my!!
Impact ballistics discussion incoming!!! I think the angle at which the projectile strikes is another major factor in the “best/better” discussion. Water filled object? Hard outer ? My mind gets lost very quickly in this stuff. There’s so much physics going on I don’t know what outweighs what and where to start to figure it out . Nooc, Sarosh , Goober !! Please enlighten us!! |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Archaic Arms on Apr 17th, 2023 at 5:22am
If the spike had a circular plate attached to the base of it (so as to not puncture the layer of balloons at the rear of the rusty) then I imagine as it hits the target, the redirected force from the rusty ball flattening out will focus behind the spike (especially if the spike meets resistance). The question is, how elastic or inelastic should the 'skin' of the rusty ball be to maximise penetration of the spike? (think balloon rubber vs kevlar fabric)
My guess is, the tougher the target, the less elasticity. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by IronGoober on Apr 17th, 2023 at 4:30pm NooneOfConsequence wrote on Apr 17th, 2023 at 12:14am:
..Yes. The peak force at the front of the spike will be super high because there is a very small area. Even though the rusty ball would lower the peak force compared to a solid mass behind the spike, it is still important. The thought experiment you are intending would need to be different to negate the importance of peak force... I'm not sure what you are getting at. I could me mis-interpreting what your intention is, but I don't think that you can equate total energy transfer to damage. Edit: Ok, so you are thinking elastic vs inelastic collisions. I guess what I'm supposition-ing (is that a word?) is that even though a hard projectile could have an elastic collision, it most likely won't. It will deform whatever it is hitting via high peak force. Supposing you had something that the projectile hits that is very hard and strong, then an elastic collision could happen, and yes, very little damage to the object (that was hit) would occur. But that would take a lot of material that was very strong. Like a pillar of concrete or a 1/2" metal plate. Most helmets or armor were not that thick. So, for a normal 1mm thick plate of steel, I would stick with my answer of hard being better. And even a rusty ball with a spike would be better than a rustyball alone. HOwever, put the rock or a rustyball against a person with a 1/2" thick helmet on that wouldn't deform, the rustyball would do better, because maybe you can shock their neck with all of the energy being transferred as opposed to the rock elastically bouncing off and not transferring as much energy. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Sarosh on Apr 18th, 2023 at 3:17am
It's the acceleration that kills. I say a helmet shot with a sling has a higher chance of getting a KO than an arrow.
But it's more probable to get an arrow to the eye at close distances than a good helmet sling shot (maybe I'm wrong). At long distances where getting an eye shot with an arrow is impossible because the angle doesnt allow it, the sling is better because of the higher momentum. Tungsten spike with lead is better than tungsten spike with rusty ball, just because of the same momentum but lower time to transfer the energy. Hard materials will get higher peak force which is higher acceleration and more chances of trauma. Knights wear padding to protect from the higher acceleration so while he is protected from above, a bounced stone to the teeth can be more effective. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by StaffSlinger on Apr 18th, 2023 at 8:36am
Back in the Olde Days I did a bunch of firearms ballistics -- damage at target and all that. What matters most to the target is the total energy transferred to it completely.
Say you shoot a deer at range X. At that range you want all of the bullet's energy transferred to the critter, leaving the bullet in the center of the mass (or at least not exiting the far side). In arrow impacts, the bodkin points used against solid armored opponents were always tipped by a drop of wax. The millisecond hesitation caused by the 'sticking' of the wax allowed the needle point to penetrate rather than skipping off the surface. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Sarosh on Apr 18th, 2023 at 11:32am StaffSlinger wrote on Apr 18th, 2023 at 8:36am:
From what I know by drilling holes on metal, it is better to use oil than drilling dry. I havent read a detailed scientific explanation for this but i've read its heat dissipation which prevents the drill bit from becoming dull. I think something similar happens on the arrow tips instead of the stickiness of the wax, further penetration would be due to the wax acting as lubricant. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Mersa on Apr 18th, 2023 at 6:23pm
Super interesting. Never thought about having a lubricant on an arrow but it makes sense, also the wax.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by IronGoober on Apr 18th, 2023 at 7:07pm StaffSlinger wrote on Apr 18th, 2023 at 8:36am:
For something that completely penetrates and is able to easily deposit the energy in a localized manner because it can penetrate (i.e. bullets) this makes sense (i.e. that total energy deposited is the major factor correlating to damage). However, for something that will likely not penetrate and spreads its force out in a less localized manner, things get more complicated with more factors contributing to the final result. At least that is my interpretation/opinion, I do not have irrefutable evidence to back this up, just a lot of empirical data from my own experimentation. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by SerKraus on Apr 20th, 2023 at 7:57pm
I think anyone that believes a sling projectile will be negated by a helmet (a useless term when the type of helmet isn't specified) has never used or been around them. Often, people who denigrate the sling's lethality don't even know how they work, or have never been exposed to a truly proficient user.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Apr 20th, 2023 at 10:30pm SerKraus wrote on Apr 20th, 2023 at 7:57pm:
Agreed. And I think the exact same statement could be made about the term "sling projectile". ;) |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 1st, 2023 at 1:16pm
Objectively speaking yes it is. There's a big caveat to that statement though.
Ill start with the good here- Yes it is good in regards to both questions, as a weapon and against armor. The reason we can say this is true is because this is a case where we can work backwards. We know its good because it was used for thousands of years. Both as a weapon in general and against armored opponents in battle. If it continued to be used for that long it was effective. We dont even have to prove why. You dont use a weapon where your life is on the line if it isnt effective. Since it continued to be used we can start with the conclusion and then endeavor to work backwards to understand why. The armor question is a good one but I wont go into theories as to what ways it might have been effective in this post. Now the bad- If you try to use this weapon to hunt with in a survival situation you will starve. This is coming from a sling fanatic. Im not hating its just true. There may be a few here that wouldnt but in general its a rather extreme diet plan. I think I understand why it was used though. Aside from the obvious that people in the past grew up using it in a culture of sling masters and had more time and incentive to practice, I think the other reason is it allows for an alternative to using expensive ammo like arrows where the arrows might be broken or lost on a missed shot. I lived in such an area for a few years and it becomes immediately obvious when you shoot handmade arrows in such an enviorment why the incentive to take a shot with a sling is such a benefit. A good set of arrows are very labor intensive. Ive made many shoot arrows and cutting, curing, straitening, culling, sizing, spining, culling more, points etc means each perfect arrow can require maybe half a days work. This comes from the amount of arrows that dont make the cut. Whereas you can easily break one in a second. So the option of using a less expensive ammo on shots becomes a big bonus. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Jul 1st, 2023 at 4:31pm
Any weapon is as good as the person wielding the weapon.I could survive with a sling.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Slyngorm on Jul 2nd, 2023 at 3:36pm Rat Man wrote on Apr 10th, 2023 at 8:39am:
Not quite unfortunately. At the very least some flight bows outperform the sling in distance. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Archaic Arms on Jul 2nd, 2023 at 3:50pm Slyngorm wrote on Jul 2nd, 2023 at 3:36pm:
The problem is that we don't actually know what ranges professional slingers were getting back in the day, thus the only thing we've got to go off are the few historical accounts that state the sling's outranging capability. I suspect that the maximum range was comparable to flight arrows, but effective range is of course, less. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Slyngorm on Jul 5th, 2023 at 3:07pm
Just realised, that talking about the sling as a weapon we can leave flight bows entirely out of the discussion.
So the sling still got that one. ;D |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by JudoP on Jul 7th, 2023 at 9:44am
Not sure where I saw it so I can't verify but I think lead ammo can fly pretty close to ideal projectile distances (i.e. it nearly ignores air resistance). That would imply that the speed of the lead projectile would be quite similar coming down as to leaving the sling and lethality would be mostly maintained all the way out to maximum range.
I'm not sure you can say the same about arrows which I believe lose a lot more oomph during flight. Specifically actual arrows intended for military use, less so flight arrows. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by StaffSlinger on Jul 8th, 2023 at 9:56am
In its times and in its places the sling was the ultimate ranged weapon. It was gradually supplanted by the bow; which was gradually supplanted by the gun, which was gradually supplanted by the....
We can compare sling-thrown glandes with shoulder-launched missiles too... but what's the point? |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by serbaz on Jul 8th, 2023 at 12:48pm
Hello!
As you are saying, the sling blunt power is really high. Yesterday, I was training with stones, and I decided to give it a go with some heavy ones, around 500gr (using a 3 braid-puouch), using as target a cardboard box with 2-3kg inside to fix it. So, at the end I threw such a heavy stone, weighing way more than 500gr, that I could just throw it 10m away, but it hit and oh, the box fell apart. The use of such heavy stones is attested by Xenophon, Anabasis; the Greeks outranged the Persians because their ligher stones, and so kept them in check. Perhaps javelins also have similar strenght, for as far as I know the pilum was also quite heavy. But still, I think a 500-700gr stone is basically unstoppable, even if it is impossible to throw it with great power |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 9th, 2023 at 1:17pm
100% agree with you serbaz. A couple years ago I did a bunch of big stone slinging. I was able to get a 765g stone out to 55 meters. And that was with very little practice. The stopping power of really big stones is quite incredible, and you can get some pretty decent distance with them too.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Jul 10th, 2023 at 5:35am
If they are defending a fortified position OK. When attacking, they have to carry ammunition with them
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Rat Man on Jul 10th, 2023 at 11:35am
Of course if you really want to hurl big stones a staff sling is the best way to go.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 10th, 2023 at 2:05pm
Good point Jaegoor. Although big stones could also be used for a quick attack and retreat, with each slinger only carrying a few.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Jul 10th, 2023 at 7:40pm
That's good in theory. Not in practice. Slingers are skirmishers. They bind enemy troops. Her strength is her mobility. In a fortified position it is different. fustiball And man blide are excellent at throwing large stones.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 10th, 2023 at 11:31pm
Yes, I think you're correct. I definitely see the issues with trying to use large stones in a traditional battle scenario. But in an ambush attack, or an initial attack when there is intention to fallback to another position, I think it could be effective. As you said, this is just theory and I think would require very specific situations.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Archaic Arms on Jul 11th, 2023 at 8:53am
I believe ~431g (one mina) is the practical limit for battle. Much heavier, and the throwing motion will start to break down.
We at least know that 350g stones were practical, as numerous were found at Lachish, used by the Assyrian slingers. I think there were different types of slingers for different roles. Some for heavy impact at close range, some for long range with lead, etc. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 11th, 2023 at 10:15am
Do we have any evidence slingers carried multiple weight stones for battle? It would make sense to use lighter stones for longer ranges then switch to heavier as they closed in.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 11th, 2023 at 12:48pm Archaic Arms wrote on Jul 11th, 2023 at 8:53am:
I absolutely agree with this. With very heavy stones you basically lose the power stroke. The heavy weight can't be accelerated fast enough with a sling. The stone needs to be put in motion, and just let go at the appropriate time. It's a very different way to throw. I would say similar in concept to a pirouette style release. Morphy wrote on Jul 11th, 2023 at 10:15am:
It wouldn't surprise me if this was done at some point. When I was slinging all the heavy stones, the distance dropped like clockwork. Once your range is known for a particular weight, that could be a pretty simple way to change distances. Although it does come with the caveat that different weights need to be carried. And if your target isn't at the correct distance, the vertical angle and/or speed of the throw will need to be adjusted anyway. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by serbaz on Jul 11th, 2023 at 2:46pm Morphy wrote on Jul 11th, 2023 at 10:15am:
As far as I know, Xenophon describes something related to that in the Anabasis, III.3.16-20. He states there that the Rhodians among the Greeks took their slings and started crafting more to defend the army from the Persian archers and slingers. These Rhodians outranged the Persians by far because, as Xenophon puts it, the stones they were using were large as a hand, while the Rhodians used lead missiles. I think this soure give some insight on the topic. Perhaps depending of the place, slingers trained with a particular stone size? Also I consider this really, really interesting: Xenophon says the Greek army gathered 200 slingers. It is a 2% out of the 10.000. Thus we could think the % of people able to shoot the sling effectively was quite small, although this specific example with no other examples can be quite inaccurate. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 11th, 2023 at 3:15pm serbaz wrote on Jul 11th, 2023 at 2:46pm:
Still, thats an interesting point and at least points to the possibility of that being correct. My experience in studying weapons through the ages is it was usually the easier weapon to master that still attained a certain minimum level of lethality that replaced the former. So it wasnt effectiveness above all. Slings are definitely difficult to master. So every dead slinger requires an increasing level of effort to replace. That may also be why there was so few. Or perhaps, as you suggest, even back then it was just too hard a weapon for the majority of people to master to a high enough level to make it into a slinger regiment. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 11th, 2023 at 3:22pm
@JoeM- Ive never considered this until now. But it makes sense. What is the alternative? Let them advance to the range of the heavier stones? When instead you could be slinging lighter, albeit less lethal, ammo at them for longer. In my mind its better to get whatever casualties you could even if it was not as effective with the lighter stones rather than letting them advance "for free" until in range of the more effective ammo.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 11th, 2023 at 10:21pm Morphy wrote on Jul 11th, 2023 at 3:22pm:
It makes me wonder how much more effective a sling is with this kind of attack vs. a bow. We're all familiar with the Hollywood scene of an army of archers shooting high into the air and watching the arrows arc across the sky to rain down on the other army. But because arrows are so much more effective when keeping the trajectory as flat as possible, I think the idea of such an attack being used (regularly) isn't really considered accurate anymore. At least not to the extent modern media portrays it. But I think a stone or glande thrown from a sling wouldn't loose as much effectiveness during such as flight as an arrow does. In general the idea of different weight seems reasonable to me. At least in scenarios where it could be used effectively. Obviously we can't say it would be a good practice for every battle. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Jul 12th, 2023 at 2:01am
Why are flat trajectory arrows more effective? You shoot high ballistics because they are effective in falling. They fall at 9.8 seconds square. That's why arrows got heavier and heavier Tensile forces of the arches increased. They rose so that one could shoot heavy arrows. Of course you can also shoot flat. In a battle with a large number of archers, this makes little sense. A Angles of about 42° give the longest range. It's no different with a sling.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 13th, 2023 at 12:05am
I'm sorry but I disagree. Gravity will never make an arrow fly faster than the bow itself. Obviously I'm speaking about bows that would be used in a battle scenario. So the longer an arrow is in flight, the more it's going to slow down. I will agree that an arrow may pick up some speed on the downward flight if it's shot at a high angle, but that's not going to be as fast as the velocity it has from the bow.
You mentioned the draw weight of the bow increasing, and therefore the size and weight of the arrows also increasing. I agree. But I don't know why you think this is for distance alone, and not for higher arrow speeds to penetrate armor. I think both intentions are valid. You said in a battle with a large number of archers it wouldn't make sense to shoot for maximum distance. I think this is entirely dependent on what you're shooting at. If you're shooting at a heavily armored army, distance shots are a waste of arrows. Here's what makes sense to me, and this is just hypothetical. If a long distance shot has a 20% chance of taking down someone in an enemy army, but a closer shot has a 60% chance (because of higher arrow velocity and better aim), I'm definitely going to wait to start shooting until hits will be most effective for the time given to shoot. I will admit without specifics of the battle situation, there's not much to argue on. Both methods (long distance and shorter distance) could both work fine depending on circumstances. And just to note, when I refer to shorter distances, I mean 80-100 meters or less. The reason I brought this point up at all was the comparison between an arrow and a projectile thrown from a sling over distance. If you shoot an arrow at 42°, the velocity difference from when it leaves the bow to the time it hits the target is going to be pretty significant. I just wonder how the ratio of the arrow would compare to a sling stone. There's definitely been many measurement examples of arrow and sling projectile speeds at (or near) release. I don't recall seeing much of anything on speeds at point of impact. Especially at distance. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 13th, 2023 at 9:35am
So the question then becomes what is the terminal velocity of an arrow vs say a 4 oz lead glande. Lead I think would have a much better terminal velocity (kind of goes without saying right lol).
Then, how high are they being cast- so as to know the max speed obtained at impact and lastly, at what speed even if its lower does an arrow point inflict greater damage than a lighter, longer range sling projectile. Now that we have chat GPT these conversations get much more interesting. Question- if a warbow shot a 1500 grain arrow at 160 fps at an angle of 42 degrees how high would it go. (Initially GPT gave a initial possible velocity of 180-240.) 240 for a 10 gpp arrow is impossible. 180 is highly unlikely.) so I chose 160 fps as the starting velocity. To determine the maximum height the arrow would reach when shot at an angle of 42 degrees with an initial speed of 160 fps, we can use the principles of projectile motion. 1. Split the initial velocity into horizontal and vertical components: The vertical component is given by v₀y = v₀ * sin(θ), where θ is the launch angle (42 degrees) and v₀ is the initial speed (160 fps). 2. Calculate the time of flight (t): The time it takes for the arrow to reach its peak height and then fall back down is given by t = (2 * v₀y) / g, where g is the acceleration due to gravity (32.2 fps²). 3. Calculate the maximum height (h): The maximum height reached by the arrow can be calculated using the equation h = (v₀y)² / (2 * g). Plugging in the values, we have: v₀ = 160 fps θ = 42 degrees g = 32.2 fps² Calculating the vertical component of the initial velocity: v₀y = 160 * sin(42) ≈ 103.28 fps Calculating the time of flight: t = (2 * 103.28) / 32.2 ≈ 6.4 seconds Calculating the maximum height: h = (103.28)² / (2 * 32.2) ≈ 167.8 feet Therefore, under these assumptions, the arrow would reach a maximum height of approximately 167.8 feet when shot at a 42-degree angle with an initial speed of 160 fps from a 150-pound warbow. how fast would a 1500 grain arrow be traveling if it fell in an arc from 167.8 feet? To determine the speed at which a 1500-grain arrow would be traveling when it falls from a maximum height of 167.8 feet, we can use the principle of conservation of energy. Assuming no air resistance, at its highest point, the arrow would only have potential energy, which would be fully converted into kinetic energy as it falls. We can equate the potential energy at the highest point to the kinetic energy at the point of impact. The potential energy at the highest point can be calculated using the equation: PE = m * g * h where m is the mass of the arrow (converted to pounds) and g is the acceleration due to gravity (32.2 fps²), and h is the maximum height (167.8 feet). The kinetic energy at the point of impact can be calculated using the equation: KE = (1/2) * m * v² where v is the velocity of the arrow at the point of impact. Since the potential energy is equal to the kinetic energy (neglecting any losses), we can set up the equation: m * g * h = (1/2) * m * v² Simplifying, we have: v² = 2 * g * h Plugging in the values, we get: m = 1500 grains (converted to pounds: 1500 / 7000 = 0.2143 lb) g = 32.2 fps² h = 167.8 feet Calculating the final velocity: v² = 2 * 32.2 * 167.8 v ≈ 148.7 fps Therefore, under these assumptions, the 1500-grain arrow would be traveling at approximately 148.7 feet per second when falling from a maximum height of 167.8 feet. This is assuming no drag so we would have to be lowering this number somewhat since arrows have fletching. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 13th, 2023 at 9:43am
The fletching would lower the max height achieved which would lower its fall velocity at impact since its starting from a lower point. One would assume it would further lower the terminal velocity but this may be a moot point since it probably(?) wouldnt reach terminal velocity within such a short fall time. So it's fair to say it might reach 130-140 fps at impact. Rough guess here but definitely not release velocity. Then comes the question of how much more effective a point impacting at a lower speed vs a lead glande impacting at a higher speed would be.
These are all very rough numbers but it gives, perhaps, a starting point? |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 13th, 2023 at 2:16pm
Good stuff Morphy. All this got me thinking, if we would be able to set up a test that could get an arrow and a sling stone/glande moving at the same velocity, comparing them by time in flight or distance traveled might be easier than trying to get a speed rating at the end of the flight. And the final speed could probably be estimated pretty closely. That would still be a tough experiment to set up though.
Here some other data just to throw it out here. This comes from and old TV series that Mike Loades did called The Weapons That Made Britain. One of the weapons he covered was the longbow (what a surprise ::)). They had a champion archer, whose name I don't have at the moment, who shot a longbow and the arrow was tracked by doppler radar. Here are the numbers: [list bull-blackball] I wish they went into more detail and show some more tests. I would have loved to see tests at different angles to show the effect of gravity based on how steep the angle is. But this information was given rather quickly and they went on to the next thing. Quite a drop in speed though over less than a second. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 13th, 2023 at 2:30pm
And idea what arrow weight was?
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by joe_meadmaker on Jul 13th, 2023 at 9:04pm
Unfortunately not. That's definitely on the list of things I would've liked to have seen.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by IronGoober on Jul 13th, 2023 at 9:59pm
My thought is that theoretical speeds based on simple physics equations are easy to calculate and put an upper bound on the speed at different distances and heights, and then you can see the effect of air drag by comparing to these.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Jul 15th, 2023 at 4:36am
Nice calculations. Maybe I'm misunderstood. There are historical examples of what I am saying.
Magyars used very fast bows. And very light arrows. At least from the horse. They were very successful with that. Until the opponent adjusted to it. That was against Ottonian Armored Riders over. Their arrows had no more effect. The historians report that they were ridden down with lances. There are similar reports from the Crusades. Few knights defended a bridge. They were riddled with arrows. But they were not killed by them. Later there was even heavier armor. A new type of bow emerged. The English Longbow. He had up to 200 pounds of traction. His arrows were heavy. The effect was devastating for Ritter. However, only for a short time. Then guns changed everything.So there is clearly a discernible effect. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by JudoP on Jul 15th, 2023 at 8:08am
Without any kind of drag factored in projectiles will follow a symmetric up and down, they hit with the exact same angle and speed as they were launched. You can never get extra impact from aiming higher otherwise you could make a perpetual motion machine.
With drag it's more complex. Heavier projectiles and more streamlined projectiles will retain more speed but every projectile will hit less hard on the way down. It's possible heavier arrows were a lot more effective for arcing fire than lighter arrows as they retain more speed/energy, even if they travel less far overall. So they could be relatively much better at that kind of artillery fire compared to lighter arrows, whilst being pretty much comparable in direct fire. |
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Jaegoor on Jul 15th, 2023 at 1:36pm
Which does more damage. A penny falling from 100 m, or a brick? Of course you can also shoot directly. There are many examples of this as well. In a battle with hundreds of shooters, however, it's all about an area-wide effect. And you tried to bind forces at a distance. A heavy arrow falling from a height of 200m does more damage than a light arrow. Force is mass times acceleration. Very easily. Therefore, krieg's bows had a higher pound number. So that you can shoot heavy arrows to a suitable height. Ballistic shooting first class.
|
|
Title: Re: Is a sling a good ranged weapon compared to others? Post by Morphy on Jul 15th, 2023 at 3:13pm
Arrows eventually won out in the arms race of history even though much more expensive per unit of fire. And heavier would definitely be better than light on armored opponents. Whereas I would assume light would be better than heavy on scantly armored opponents due to much greater range while still retaining enough lethality ro do the job. After all you cant make someone more dead with a heavier shot.
Even if the shot is slower coming back down it would still retain plenty of energy to kill a person. |
|
Slinging.org Forum » Powered by YaBB 2.5.2! YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2026. All Rights Reserved. |